Italy fines Meta €805 million for default Android gallery access
Italy's data protection authority fined Meta €805 million because Facebook for Android accessed user photos by default without explicit consent.
Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805 million for a privacy breach involving the Facebook app on Android. The penalty addresses a feature that suggests photos and videos from users' device galleries for posting, which was enabled by default without obtaining explicit consent from Italian users.
The ruling mandates that Meta disable this feature by default within 60 days and implement a separate, clear consent mechanism for all users, including those who previously granted general gallery permissions.
What happened
The investigation focused on a feature introduced in 2023 that allows the Facebook app to suggest content from a user’s local photo and video library. The Garante found that the app accessed these files and their associated metadata without specific, informed consent. Instead of asking users directly about this specific functionality, the app relied on a broad Android permission request that covered multiple functions simultaneously.
This general permission notice did not clearly inform users that granting access would also enable the gallery suggestion feature. Consequently, the app could read the entire photo archive on an ongoing basis. The authority noted that neither users nor regulators could easily verify which specific information was actually processed or used by the application after access was granted.
The complaint that triggered this investigation was filed by Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection group based in Bolzano. In July 2025, the group advised users to manually disable gallery suggestions and review their app permissions. The Garante began its technical analysis shortly after, concluding that the practice violated Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which implements the EU’s ePrivacy Directive.
Meta has announced plans to appeal the decision, describing the fine as disproportionate. A spokesperson stated that the feature only operates after users grant device-level permission and emphasized that users can revoke this access at any time through their settings. However, the regulator maintained that the initial consent was not free or informed enough to meet legal standards.
How it works
Under the EU’s ePrivacy Directive, as transposed into Italian law, a mobile phone is considered an extension of a person’s private life. This legal framework requires that any access to data stored on the device must be preceded by free and informed consent. This requirement applies regardless of whether the data is transmitted to external servers or if any actual harm occurs to the user.
The core issue was the bundling of permissions. The Facebook app requested a single, broad permission to access the gallery, which covered various features with different purposes. The user interface presented a general notice about enabling features, but it failed to distinguish the gallery suggestion tool from other functionalities. This lack of granularity meant users could not consent to one function while rejecting another.
Because the permission was granted globally for the app, it allowed continuous reading of the photo archive. The Garante argued that this setup prevented users from making a specific choice about the suggestion feature. The authority rejected Meta’s argument that Ireland’s data protection authority should handle the case, noting that the ePrivacy rules do not support the one-stop-shop mechanism used for GDPR cases.
Key details
- The fine amounts to €805 million, representing approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue.
- The breach affects roughly 20 million Android users in Italy.
- Meta has 60 days to disable the feature by default and request separate consent.
- The company must report on its progress within 30 days and on completed measures within 90 days.
- The violation concerns Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, derived from the EU ePrivacy Directive.
- The investigation did not examine whether the data was used to train AI models, though a newer cloud-processing feature may face separate scrutiny.
Why it matters
For software engineers and product leaders, this case highlights the risks of bundling permissions in mobile applications. Relying on broad system-level permissions to enable specific features can lead to significant regulatory penalties, even if the user technically granted access. Regulators are increasingly demanding granular consent, where each distinct data processing activity is explained and approved separately.
The decision also underscores that compliance is not just about data transmission but about local access. Even if data remains on the device, accessing private storage requires explicit user approval. This sets a precedent for how apps must handle local resources like contacts, photos, and files, forcing developers to redesign permission flows to be more transparent and specific.
Furthermore, the rejection of the one-stop-shop argument for ePrivacy violations means that companies may face direct enforcement actions in individual member states. This fragments the compliance landscape, requiring legal and engineering teams to account for national variations in how privacy directives are implemented, rather than relying solely on centralized EU-level decisions.
What you can do
- Audit your app’s permission requests to ensure they are specific to the feature being enabled.
- Implement separate consent dialogs for distinct functionalities that access sensitive local data.
- Review your privacy notices to ensure they clearly explain what data is accessed and why.
- Disable data-intensive features by default until explicit, informed consent is obtained.
- Prepare for potential national-level enforcement actions by understanding local implementations of EU directives.
- Document your consent flows thoroughly to demonstrate compliance during potential investigations.



